Judge Prudence C. Beatty

All Written Opinions (published and non-published since April 2005)

Show recent opinions first

In Re: Kittay v. Gelbwaks      Date Filed: 06/09/2005
case number: 03-08978-pcb     81322_15_opinion.pdf
Written Opinion signed on 6/9/2005 vacating order denying debtor's discharge. (related document(s)[9], [8])

In Re: Frank's Nursery & Crafts, Inc.      Date Filed: 07/22/2005
case number: 04-15826-pcb     110326_1354_opinion.pdf
Order signed 7/21/05 approving stipulation resolving claim asserted by 1081 EJT, LLC against the debtor's estate.

In Re: GT Brands Holdings LLC      Date Filed: 09/02/2005
case number: 05-15167-pcb     129210_198_opinion.pdf
Memoranum Decision Signed on 9/2/2005 So Ordered Regarding Agreement (related document(s)[19]).

In Re: First Quality Realty, LLC      Date Filed: 02/17/2006
case number: 02-14758-pcb     58511_129_opinion.pdf
Memorandum Decision signed on 2/17/2006, Granting Debtor's Motion to Disqualify Arbitrator and Vacate Arbitration Award. (related document(s)85).

In Re: North American Energy Conservation, Inc.      Date Filed: 02/17/2006
case number: 01-03633-pcb     43849_20_opinion.pdf
Memorandum Decision signed on 2/17/2006 Granting Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment. (Related Doc # 16).

In Re: Cosmetics Plus Group Ltd. et al v. American International Group, Inc. et al      Date Filed: 06/19/2006
case number: 03-08032-pcb     66334_16_opinion.pdf
Written Opinion signed on 6/19/2006. Memorandum Decision Granting Debtors' Leave to Amend Complaint.

In Re: Official Committee Of Equity Security Holders Of S v. Monsanto Company et al      Date Filed: 09/14/2006
case number: 05-01202-pcb     119792_50_opinion.pdf
Written Opinion signed on 9/14/2006 On Issue Of Standing. (related document(s)[31], [36])

In Re: Villa Luisa, LLC      Date Filed: 10/17/2006
case number: 04-10639-pcb     94052_95_opinion.pdf
Written Opinion Signed on 10/12/2006 Regarding Denial of Administrative Expense Claim.

In Re: Geltzer v. Cohen      Date Filed: 03/06/2007
case number: 01-03570-pcb     42681_14_opinion.pdf
Memorandum Decision Granting Trustee's Motion for Summary Judgement and Denying Debtor's Discharge; signed on 3/6/2007

In Re: Wilmington Trust Company v. Solutia, Inc.      Date Filed: 05/01/2007
case number: 05-01843-pcb     126291_146_opinion.pdf
Written Opinion/ Memorandum Decision After Trial signed on 5/1/2007.

In Re: Wilmington Trust Company v. Solutia, Inc.      Date Filed: 05/22/2007
case number: 05-01843-pcb     126291_148_opinion.pdf
Errata Order /Written Opinion signed on 5/22/2007 Regarding Memorandum Decision After Trial. (related document(s)[146])

In Re: CIS Corporation      Date Filed: 05/31/2007
case number: 89-10073-pcb     91787_5165_opinion.pdf
Memorandum Decision Signed on 5/31/2007 Debying The Motion To Reconsider Order Directing Release of Unclaimed Funds (related document(s)[5157], [5155])

In Re: Genuity Solutions Inc. v. Metropolitan Transportation Authority      Date Filed: 06/20/2007
case number: 03-93469-pcb     89397_29_opinion.pdf
Memorandum Decision signed on 6/20/2007

In Re: RBA SOUTHAMPTON HILLS, LLC et al v. Levine et al      Date Filed: 07/10/2007
case number: 02-03492-pcb     61504_121_opinion.pdf
Written Opinion signed on 7/10/2007.

In Re: The Parkway Hospital, Inc.      Date Filed: 07/31/2007
case number: 05-14876-pcb     128731_546_opinion.pdf
Findings Of Fact, Conclusions Of Law And Order Confirming The First Amended Plan Of Reorganization Of The Parkway Hospital Inc. Dated April 17, 2007 And Granting Related Relied signed on 7/31/2007 (related document(s)[416]).

In Re: Duncraggen Realty Corp.      Date Filed: 08/29/2007
case number: 92-40605-pcb     42365_187_opinion.pdf
Memorandum Decision signed on 8/29/2007, Granting Motion to Permit Payment of Contribution Fee (related document(s)[174])

In Re: AARM CORP. v. Rosenthal & Rosenthal, Inc.      Date Filed: 09/17/2007
case number: 04-04408-pcb     112884_22_opinion.pdf
Written Opinion/Memorandum Decision signed on 9/14/2007 RE: granting Motion for partial summary judgment (related document(s)[9]).

In Re: AARM Corp.      Date Filed: 09/17/2007
case number: 02-14232-pcb     57118_38_opinion.pdf
Written Opinion/Memorandum Decision signed on 9/14/2007 RE: Granting Rosenthal Motion for partial summary judgment in Adversary Case No. 04-4408.

In Re: Cosmetics Plus Group Ltd. et al v. American International Group, Inc. et al      Date Filed: 10/25/2007
case number: 03-08032-pcb     66334_21_opinion.pdf
Written Opinion : Memorandum Decision signed on 10/24/2007 Partially Granting Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment and Denying Cross-Motion.

In Re: Solutia Inc.      Date Filed: 11/09/2007
case number: 03-17949-pcb     90572_4307_opinion.pdf
Written Opinion MEMORANDUM DECISION SIGNED ON 11/9/2007 ON JOINT MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT WITH RESPECT TO CLAIM NO. 6210 (11.25% SENIOR SECURED NOTES).

In Re: Greenwich Insurance Company v. Greenwich Street Capital Partners II, L.P.      Date Filed: 03/06/2008
case number: 03-06364-pcb     77694_15_opinion.pdf
Written Opinion signed on 3/6/2008 Re: Memorandum Decision Granting Motion of Summary Judgment of GSCP and Denying Cross-Motion of Greenwich.

In Re: Lawrence Slater      Date Filed: 03/19/2008
case number: 03-16647-pcb     86846_38_opinion.pdf
Written Opinion: Memorandum Decision signed on 3/19/2008. (related document(s)[28])

In Re: The Parkway Hospital, Inc. v. Long & Albert      Date Filed: 03/27/2008
case number: 06-01429-pcb     148527_9_opinion.pdf
Written Opinion signed on 3/27/2008 Denying Motion for Approval of Settlement (related document(s)[4]).

In Re: Madison Equities, LLC v. Condren      Date Filed: 04/11/2008
case number: 04-04718-pcb     115417_12_opinion.pdf
Written Opinion Signed on 4/11/2008 Granting Motion to Dismiss as to both the Debtor and Condren (related document(s)[5])

In Re: Theatre Row Phase II Associates, LP      Date Filed: 04/11/2008
case number: 03-10134-pcb     64083_205_opinion.pdf
Written Opinion Signed on 4/11/2008 Granting Motion to Dismiss as to both the Debtor and Condren.

In Re: Holmes v. Burrell      Date Filed: 08/06/2008
case number: 06-01715-pcb     151087_17_opinion.pdf
Memorandum Decision Signed on 8/6/2008 Granting Motion To Dismiss the first and third counts of the Amended Complaint with prejudice. The motion to dismiss the second count is denied without prejudice except as to issues decided in this opinion. Asmovant, the Debtor is directed to settle an appropriate order in accordance with this court's rulings on 20 day notice.

In Re: Metro Affiliates, Inc.      Date Filed: 08/26/2008
case number: 02-42560-pcb     56430_1415_opinion.pdf
Written Opinion, signed 8/26/2008: Memorandum Decision Granting Debtor's Motion for Summary Judgment Expunging Claim No. 987 and Denying Claimant's Motion for Additional Discovery.

In Re: Liebert v. Berger et al      Date Filed: 09/05/2008
case number: 04-02966-pcb     101553_17_opinion.pdf
Written Opinion Signed on 9/5/2008 RE: Memorandum Decision Denying Both the Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment and the Trustee's Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment.

In Re: Liebert v. Berger et al      Date Filed: 09/05/2008
case number: 04-02966-pcb     101553_17_opinion.pdf
Written Opinion Signed on 9/5/2008 RE: Memorandum Decision Denying Both the Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment and the Trustee's Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment.

In Re: Liebert v. Berger et al      Date Filed: 09/05/2008
case number: 04-02966-pcb     101553_17_opinion.pdf
Written Opinion Signed on 9/5/2008 RE: Memorandum Decision Denying Both the Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment and the Trustee's Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment.

In Re: Liebert v. Berger et al      Date Filed: 09/05/2008
case number: 04-02966-pcb     101553_17_opinion.pdf
Written Opinion Signed on 9/5/2008 RE: Memorandum Decision Denying Both the Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment and the Trustee's Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment.

In Re: Liebert v. Berger et al      Date Filed: 09/05/2008
case number: 04-02966-pcb     101553_17_opinion.pdf
Written Opinion Signed on 9/5/2008 RE: Memorandum Decision Denying Both the Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment and the Trustee's Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment.

In Re: 130/40 Essex St. Dev. Corp. v. City of New York et al      Date Filed: 10/27/2008
case number: 04-02978-pcb     101798_19_opinion.pdf
Memorandum Decision Signed on 10/22/2008 Granting Motion To Dismiss Complaint (related document(s)[8])

In Re: Revere Copper and Brass, Inc.      Date Filed: 02/02/2009
case number: 82-12073-pcb     1924_653_opinion.pdf
Memorandum Decision Signed on 2/2/2009 Fixing Amount of Claim No.: 907 - Fairchild Holding Corporation.

In Re: Solutia Inc.      Date Filed: 03/24/2009
case number: 03-17949-pcb     90572_4758_opinion.pdf
Written Opinion signed on 3/23/2009 on Fee Application of THE NITRO, WEST VIRGINIA TORT CLAIMANTS'. (related document(s)[4757], [4691])

In Re: Anchev v. 335 West 38th Street Cooperative Corp. et al      Date Filed: 04/15/2009
case number: 03-08264-pcb     73900_29_opinion.pdf
Written Opinion signed on 4/15/2009 RE: Motion to Remand Adversary Proceeding.

In Re: 251 West 121 Street, Inc.      Date Filed: 12/10/2009
case number: 03-14377-pcb     76512_124_opinion.pdf
Memorandum Decision Re:David N. Addison and Ida Fuller signed on 12/10/2009. (related document(s)[123])

In Re: 251 West 121 Street, Inc.      Date Filed: 12/30/2009
case number: 03-14377-pcb     76512_131_opinion.pdf
Memorandum Decision signed on 12/30/2009 Denying Motion for Reconsideration and Denying Stay Pending Appeal.